RRK Holding Co. v. Sears, Roebuck & Co., No. 04-CV-3944, Verdict (N.D. Ill. Nov. 19, 2007)
A family-owned Wisconsin company that makes power tools recently won a $21.5 million verdict against Sears, Roebuck and Co. after the jury found the national retailer guilty of stealing the design for the popular Craftsman all-in-one cutting tool. Plaintiff RRK Holding Co., formerly known as Roto Zip, convinced the federal jury in Chicago that Sears had willfully and wantonly misappropriated its trade secrets under the Illinois Trade Secret Act and breached the parties’ nondisclosure agreement.
In the late 1990s, Roto Zip was one of Sears’ major suppliers of the rotary saw. The suit alleged that in 1999, pursuant to a nondisclosure agreement, Roto Zip disclosed to Sears drafts for a next generation, hand-held combination power saw, but after negotiations broke down over price, Sears declined to make a deal. Instead, Sears took the design to a Chinese manufacturer for lower-cost production. Unaware of Sears’ breach of the nondisclosure agreement, Roto Zip continued to develop the tool to bring it to market. While Roto Zip’s finished product sold for $119, Sears’ Craftsman combination tool undercut at just $59. Sales of Roto Zip’s rotary saw declined dramatically after the Sears version launched.
The $21.5 million verdict includes $13.5 million for lost profits and an additional $8 million in punitive damages. Sears plans to appeal. http://www.suntimes.com/news/metro/658969,CST-NWS-tool20.article; http://ip.law360.com/secure/ViewArticle.aspx?Id=41303